Learn how to validate your startup idea by pre-selling it, for only $80 (includes a free 1-hour consultancy call).

Amazon Auction

Online Auction platform
Amazon Cemetery
Multiple Reasons


In 1999, Amazon introduced auctions to its already popular website. With Amazon Auctions, individuals and small businesses could conduct auctions which consumers could bid on.

In order to get a share of the market from its rival eBay, Amazon introduced some additional features and planned to use its existing customer base to promote the service. Users looking up products would see listings of products being auctioned alongside the ones being sold. Amazon also gave customers a $250 anti-fraud guarantee through which users could get their money back if the products didn’t turn out as advertised in the auction.


Mention's White Logo

Mention helps you take charge of your social media workflow, thanks to their suite of powerful social monitoring and scheduling features. Check out their free guide, to help take your first steps into designing a workflow that works for you.

Cause of Failure

By 2001, Amazon was scaling back its widely publicized auction business. This was marked by a reduction in customer service and staff layoffs as Amazon shifted its focus onto other horizons. Despite all the hype surrounding the platform, it took only two years for Amazon’s enthusiasm to die down as it slowly started neglecting the service.

Just one year after Auctions launched, Amazon stopped making the effort to promote it as a featured service. It probably didn’t help that many of Amazon’s charter merchants started pulling out soon after the launch. Merchants complained that shoppers who were largely uninformed about the auction format were bidding too low for expensive objects. There were also complaints by customers highlighting that the merchants’ prices were too high. This mismatch caused dissatisfaction on both sides of the marketplace.

Amazon auctions clearly did not meet the company’s expectations of profitability and popularity. Unsurprisingly, dislodging a well-established online monopoly like eBay proved to be a very hard task (Google+ and Facebook being the most notorious similar examples).


The All-In-One Newsletter for Startup Founders

Every week, I’ll send you Failory’s latest interviews and articles and 3 curated resources for founders. Join +20,000 other startup founders!