❌ Failed startup
✅ Successful startup

140 Canvas: +17,000 visitors, 20 sales - The failed non-validated startup

After dropping out of university, Harry went back home and found a gift: a fake big tweet from Federer. That’s when he came with a business idea: fake tweets printed and sold for £30. He partnered with a friend and launched the project within 2 months. However, after a Youtube’s influencer campaign, the site got 17,000 visitors and only 20 sales. That’s when they realized not so many people were interested in their product...

United Kingdom
e-Commerce
No MVP Validation
Bad Marketing

Harry Dry

July 17, 2019

Sponsor Failory and get your business & product in front of +20,000 CEOs, startup founders, entrepreneurs, developers and marketers every month.

Do you want to grow your business? With GenM you can get free marketing from an apprentice as part of their training. The student will work 40 hours per month creating content, increasing SEO rankings, carrying out advertisement campaigns...

Want to take ownership over the growth of your business, but don't know where to start? Get 1-on-1 advice from vetted growth experts about your business.

No more changing developers every time you start a new project. With our full range of development services, no project is too big, too complex, too mobile or too software for us to complete. We’re the only web-dev partner you’ll ever need.

A 5-minute read that's informative, witty and free? That's Morning Brew — the daily email that delivers the latest news from Wall Street to Silicon Valley.

Hi Harry! What motivated you to start a business?

Hi, I’m Harry Dry, 23 years old.

Well, I’d just left university. I “studied” Economics and to be honest though the whole thing was a complete waste of time. I had no interest in sitting in a suit and bullshitting about Macroeconomics for my next 50 years.

So I started learning to code. Began with Code Academy, then I found the Net Ninja, Wes Bos, Level Up Tuts who taught me pretty much everything I know.

I’ve always been a big believer in real-world experience. There’s “blog post knowledge” and then there’s “DIY” knowledge. One thing is watching a Wes Bos copying some code and another is getting out there in the real world and doing it yourself.

So that was the reason I started my first business. Real coding. Real experience. Real money. I just needed an idea...

Harry with 2 140 Canvas


Why 140 Canvas?

Well, I’d got back from university, arrived back at my parent's house and there were these huge canvases hanging on my bedroom wall. My friend Giles bought them for me as a gift for finishing my degree.

On the canvases were tweets from Roger Federer and David Luiz. Originally it was pretty surreal, “What, has Roger Federer tweeted me!”

I realized they were fake when I noticed that Jeremy Corbyn, Theresa May and Donald Trump had liked them. But I still, it was a really thoughtful gift.

I just got really excited by these canvases. So I thought this is it. I’m going to try and build a website which allows you to write up one of these custom tweets and purchase them as canvas prints online.


How did you build it?

Well, funnily enough, I’d just done Learn Node by Wes Bos so I built the whole thing in Node and Pug which was the stack Wes used. This took me about one and a half months.

But unfortunately, that stack fell down at the final hurdle. I couldn’t get the text on the editable tweet to go blue when someone used a # or @ key. So I started from scratch. Did another Wes Bos course, React for Beginners course and built the whole thing in that which took me another month.

At the time I thought this made sense. And that the site had to be perfect. Wow, how wrong I was. Looking back now converting the whole site from Pug to React purely for this blue text effect was a really really awful idea. I just naively had it in my head that things had to be perfect.

At that time I didn’t have anyone there to say to me, “Oh, by the way, you definitely shouldn’t change the whole codebase over because of some inconsequential highlighting problem. Look at the bigger picture.”

And when it’s just yourself making decisions in a vacuum your mind can play tricks on you. I just wanted it to be perfect.

140 Canvas Landing Page

Whilst I was building the site my co-founder Giles was sorting out suppliers. I think he just called up about twenty printers in the UK and American and claimed he was starting some venture capital canvas company so he persuaded one or two to offer discounts.

Hire digital marketing interns. 40 hours for $49/month.

Learn More!

AD

Send mass personalized emails. All inside Gmail.

Want the highest email open rates you’ve ever seen? Try GMass, a Chrome extension that turns Gmail into the ultimate sales and email marketing tool. Land in the inbox this holiday season and get more sales for your startup.

Try It Now

From Wall Street to Silicon Valley...

Are you busy? Sure you are — that's why you need Morning Brew. It's a free daily email that gives a quick 5-minute rundown of the day's top business news. Join the 925,000+ people who start their day with Morning Brew!

👉 Learn More!

Reach +20,000 Startup Founders!

If you are looking to get your product in front of founders, CEOs, VPs, web and mobile developers, makers, consultants, marketers, bloggers, product managers, and many other thought leaders, then we can help you.

👉 Sponsorships

Which were your marketing strategies to grow your business?

So about two months later I’d finished the website and we were ready to go. I posted in on Product Hunt and it got an initial burst of traffic. But slowly and surely the traffic was drying up and we realized we needed to do something a bit different. 

Thankfully my co-founder Giles had come up with an idea. He said we should post our canvases to YouTubers around the world who do this thing called “Mail Time”. Now, “Mail Time” is a type of video where YouTubers open fan mail and show it off to the camera. So we thought, this could be a wild way to get our startup some exposure.

We found ten YouTubers who did regular Mail Time videos, wrote ten funny tweets, printed them off as A1 Canvases, and shipped them to their PO boxes around the world.

A couple of weeks passed and a YouTuber called Chilly did a MailTime video and opened our canvas on camera. She was so impressed by our gift that she gave a free shoutout to our website in the description and even pinned my comment. This video ended up getting 3.3 million views.

Next up, this Youtuber called Sodapoppin does a MailTime and opens our canvas. That video got 400k views.

In terms of why it worked, I think it was all the little details we went to.

Whilst most companies sending products included formal letters and sleek packaging we did the complete opposite. We bought glitter, fancy cards, bubblewrap, Christmas wrapping paper, and hand wrote personal letters.

This certainly bought us goodwill with the YouTubers who were more than up for shouting out our product.

In total, we spent £250 spent, 2 out of 10 hit rate, 3.7 million views. and 17k Uniques our site.

Results from Youtube Campaign


Which were the causes of 140 Canvas failure?

So we got 17k people to the landing page from our YouTube promotions and we’d thought we’d hit the big time. Amazingly, only converted 20 or so converted to actual sales. So it doesn’t take a genius to work out that there was a problem with the landing page.

It wasn’t badly designed either but I just think the product was too complicated.

If you on onto the landing page to try and purchase a tweet, you’ll see that you have to actually write the tweet yourself. There was no template’s you could buy. 

From our analytics, we saw a lot of people click on the box but and never make purchases. I think the actual act of coming up with an original tweet was too much effort.

I confirmed my suspicions here when I saw Framed Tweets pop up. It’s a similar concept, but they allow you to just purchase default tweets. For example a funny Kanye West tweet. According to a Starter Story article they’re making> 300k / year.

If you had to start over, what would you do differently?

I wouldn’t have done anything upfront. Instead, I’d have gone out into the market and checked there was actually demand.

I spent two months designing and redesigning the website, Giles had spent time negotiating print discounts with suppliers in America and the UK, We had a nice logo, we printed stickers, we ticked every box, but none of that really mattered…

Because we never took the time to validate the product. And that’s why despite getting all that traffic we had nothing to show for it.

There’s a cool story about Patrick McKenzie (@patio11) where he talks about going directly into hair salons, paying for appointments, just to talk to the hairdressers and try and figure out if there’s demand for a barbershop booking service.

We basically should have done the equivalent of this. Perhaps, went back to our old school with a couple of demo canvases, talked to the kids, see if they understood the product, see if they were willing to pay £30 for it, whether they even used twitter, or understood the concept.

Your one-stop shop for everything dev-related.

Anything you need, our devs can build: complex e-commerce solutions, custom software or SaaS, beautiful WordPress websites… anything. We’ll fix, upgrade & customize your website, so you never have to worry about troubleshooting web stuff ever again.

Let’s get to work!

Grow your business. Get 1-on-1 calls with +100 mentors.

Learn More!

AD

Which were your expenses? Did you achieve some revenue? In the end, how much money did you lose?

The YouTube promotion must have cost about £250. That was pretty much our only cost. Well web and domain hosting might have been another £20.

We must have sold about 25 canvases in total. Profit on each canvas was about £5.

So £270 - £125 = £145

So we probably lost about £145 in total.

140 Canvas +10 Tweets

But I like to look at it like this. 2 months time and £145 loss is really not much for the lessons it taught me. Some people spend a couple of years and hundreds of thousands for the same lesson,

This failure taught me all the fundamental lessons:

  • Validating an idea, 
  • Ship early
  • Audience before product

Unless I can validate a project upfront, build the MVP in a month, and know how I’m going to get my first 100 users, I’m not going to start a new project now.


Which are your favorite entrepreneurial resources?

In terms of communities, I feel I like the Indie Hackers. I also like another group called Work In Progress.

Pieter Levels has a very no bullshit attitude to startups which I like. I’m also inspired by the lifestyle of Vincent and Marie who are building Threader. They left Paris and just started traveling around doing their own thing at their own pace. They kinda said “fuck you” to what society said that they should be doing so that definitely fuels me.

I also think people could learn a lot from Tyson Fury and Kanye West. Not only are they both superb self-promoters but they’re also out there, two unshackled minds, playing in the sandpit, living their best life.

And I think we’d all benefit from a dose of that.

And as far as tools go, I use Sketch for Design and VSCode to code.

Funnily enough, I’d say the most inspiring bootstrapper tales you can read is one I wrote myself haha!  It’s called The Kanye Story. It’s the story of how I went from lying in bed with zero ideas to negotiating with the biggest superstar on planet Earth! 

Failory's Recommendation: Check out this talk from Harry on how to validate startup ideas, where he talks a little bit about 140 Canvas' story and what he did different in his next startup, The Kanye Story.


Where can we go to learn more?

I’m currently working on Marketing Examples. A gallery of real world marketing examples for all the marketers out there.

There’s some great advice Naval Ravikant once gave: “Build the product only you can build.” And that was the driving force behind Marketing Examples. “What are my unique talents, what can I make that no-one else in the world can. Even if they tried. Even if they had money.” And this is what I came up with.

The Marketing Examples Twitter account is also worth checking out. I distill each example into a simple easy to digest thread. And I tweet a more freely about how to unprogram yourself on my personal twitter.

Remember you can find 140 Canvas' landing page here.

✉️ Subscribe to receive weekly startup related articles!

We’re always digging for more stories like 140 Canvas. Sign up for our newsletter to keep updated on the latest additions.

👇 Other Interviews

Bugfender: Scaling an Internal Remote Logger to €9,000/Month
By 
Jordi Giménez
  •  
February 21, 2019
Spain
Web Application
Up to 50K
MealSurfers: Exiting a $7K/Month Food Startup
By 
Ali Jiwani
  •  
November 3, 2019
Canada
Food
Up to 50K
Flexiple: $80K/month connecting startups with developers
By 
Suvansh Bansal
  •  
September 26, 2019
India
Web Application
Below 150K
Gadget Flow: Building a Site in 24 Hours and Growing it to +$2M/Year
By 
Evan Varsamis
  •  
February 21, 2019
United States
Web Application
Over 150K
Urban Masterclass: Making $10,296 Teaching How to Make and Sell Music
By 
Chris Schwartze
  •  
February 21, 2019
Netherlands
Blog
Up to 50K
LiveAgent: Making +$250K in MRR with a Spin-Off Project
By 
David Cacik
  •  
February 21, 2019
United States
SaaS
Over 150K
Profitabilly: Shutting Down a Profitable Side-Project
By 
Natagon
  •  
May 9, 2019
Indonesia
SaaS
No Passion
Birdy: No Monetizing Plan = Failure
By 
Corey Maass
  •  
March 16, 2018
United States
App
Capital
Monetizing Issues
Addressbin: Problems of Being a Technical Solo Founder
By 
Adam Bard
  •  
March 16, 2018
Canada
Web Application
Bad Marketing
No Passion
The Punjab Kitchen: Failing to Overcome Competitors Prices
By 
Amit Gogia
  •  
August 30, 2018
India
Food
Big Competitors
Waterproof Digital Camera: From $250/Month to Failure
By 
Primoz Cigler
  •  
March 17, 2018
Slovenia
Blog
Bad Marketing
BeehiveID: The $70,000 Startup Killed by Facebook Data
By 
Mary Haskett
  •  
March 17, 2018
United States
Technology
Not Practical