LuckyUnicorn t-Shirts
We've just launched 20 limited edition Failory t-shirts. Click here to buy one!

❌ Failed startup
✅ Successful startup

Autto.in: Burning $15,000 in Customer Acquisition

Autto.in was an on-demand doorstep car service provider, created by Deepak in 2017. Soon after launching, a co-founder joined him and they started marketing the startup, spending a lot of money in customer acquisition. As money burnt, they decided to reach investors, who put them pressure in growing fast. After some months, they decided to shut down.

India
Transportation
Capital
People Management

Deepak Murthy

April 11, 2018

Sponsor Failory and get your business & product in front of +20,000 CEOs, startup founders, entrepreneurs, developers and marketers every month.

Do you want to grow your business? With GenM you can get free marketing from an apprentice as part of their training. The student will work 40 hours per month creating content, increasing SEO rankings, carrying out advertisement campaigns...

Do you want to grow your business? With GenM you can get free marketing from an apprentice as part of their training. The student will work 40 hours per month for only $49.

Want to take ownership over the growth of your business, but don't know where to start? Get 1-on-1 advice from vetted growth experts about your business.

A 5-minute read that's informative, witty and free? That's Morning Brew — the daily email that delivers the latest news from Wall Street to Silicon Valley.

Hi Deepak! What's your background, and what are you currently working on?

Hey Failory! My name is Deepak Murthy and I am a mechanical engineering who has worked in various roles in the automotive industry for 12 years, ranging from design engineer to software developer, and currently residing in Bangalore, India.

I am currently working at a media company in India, managing the engineering group as Program Manager. But before this, I failed to build Autto.in.

What was Autto.in about?

Autto.in was an on-demand doorstep car service provider, which operated in the city of Hyderabad, India. Our service consisted of sending mechanics to the doorstep of car owners who required general maintenance services, such as oil change, spark plug change, battery change, among others.

As a car owner, I used to find going to the automotive dealer garages very expensive, as my car was out of warranty. And, apart from the big costs, I had some bad experiences with an authorized garage.

This motivated me to solve this problem by myself, by asking mechanics to visit me and fix the car in front of me.

What went into building the initial product?

I began the business, by first figuring out how to procure genuine auto parts. In India, retail availability of genuine car parts is a big challenge, given that many spurious parts are sold, making it hard to differentiate them from the original ones.

Luckily, a few phone calls to Bosch, got me into meeting their local sales head who helped me to get in touch with genuine distributors.

In parallel to this, I started searching reliable mechanics. My idea was to start with just one mechanic, full-time hired and based on traction & demand expand. I was lucky again, as, after screening 8 candidates, I got a really good one.

I initially called the company GeniusMechanic and bought the domain on GoDaddy. The idea was to make it SEO friendly and get customers by ranking for different keywords. I built the website really simple, using Tilda. However, after receiving some feedback from friends and customers, I decided to rename GeniusMechanic to Autto.in.

After getting some customer traction, I decided it was time to build a website with a booking feature. Again, without coding, I was able to do it really quickly, using Bubble, which is a UI based app builder, and Chatra, which allowed me to embed on the site a chat application to receive customer bookings.

Hire digital marketing interns. 40 hours for $49/month.

Learn More!

AD

40 Hours of Digital Marketing for $49/Month

Do you want to grow your business? With GenM you can get free marketing from an apprentice as part of their training. The student will work 40 hours per month for only $49.

👉 Learn More!

Reach +20,000 Startup Founders!

If you are looking to get your product in front of founders, CEOs, VPs, web and mobile developers, makers, consultants, marketers, bloggers, product managers, and many other thought leaders, then we can help you.

👉 Sponsorships

Which marketing strategies did you use to attract your first customers?

The first strategy we used, was really simple. It consisted of distributing leaflets across a small community of 2000 houses. Given that we converted only 1 customer, we decided to try other strategies.

The next strategy was guerrilla marketing, which consisted of setting up car service camps in large apartment communities, with more than 2000 flats. This method proved to be very successful in attracting new customers, but it was really expensive.

On our very first stall, we provided services to 25 cars in only two days, which was a much higher conversion rate than the leaflets. But at the same time, the cost per customer acquisition was at $12. Moreover, we also conducted some service camps on weekends, when most people were at home instead of working, which gave us better results.

To reduce the acquisition cost of customers, we introduced a free eco-wash with every service bought. Surprisingly, many customers wanted just the eco-wash as a paid service. So, we introduced it with a great success. But we then realized we were losing money per wash. In India, most cars in apartments are washed and cleaned by washing facilities located within the apartment communities. Therefore, to compete against them we had to underprice massively.

Which were the causes of Autto.in's failure?

The shutdown was primarily due to two reasons:

  1. Our burn rate was high & the retention lifecycle of a customer was very long (10-12 months).
  2. In 2017, the Indian government made an announcement on the possibility of phasing out gasoline vehicles and going all electric by 2030. As we were part of the YC Startup School in 2017, and we were fortunate to connect with mentors and successful businessmen, we were asked to watch for long-term signs of the shrinking gasoline market. In a matter of a few days, I decided to shut down Autto.in. I came to the conclusion not work on building a company that may not last more than 15 years.

 

What were the biggest challenges you faced and obstacles you overcame?

Our biggest challenge was hiring. Hiring full-time mechanics meant paying them even when we had no work. But we believed that hiring meant that mechanics were always ready to go and that they were of higher quality.

We learned that we needed to have a continual hiring process and that a high attrition was the norm in the industry. Unfortunately, we were never able to completely solve this problem.

Another mistake we made was trying to expand so quickly. After meeting many investors, we were always told that our numbers were too low. This got us into a bad cycle of trying to acquire as many customers as possible, using the fastest methods. This ended up causing the resignation of many mechanics, due to too the big work demand.

From Wall Street to Silicon Valley...

Are you busy? Sure you are — that's why you need Morning Brew. It's a free daily email that gives a quick 5-minute rundown of the day's top business news. Join the 925,000+ people who start their day with Morning Brew!

👉 Learn More!

Grow your business. Get 1-on-1 calls with +100 mentors.

Learn More!

AD

Which were your investments? Did you achieve some revenue? Did you lose any money?

The entire startup was self-funded from my life savings. Also, a friend from school chipped in with a bit. In USD it was approximately $15,000.

We made a total revenue of about $5,000 which meant we lost about $10,000.

If you had to start over, what would you do differently?

In the beginning, I focused on growing slowly with a great focus on quality. As funds were running out, I started meeting with investors and startup founders and thereby, shifting to fundraising too soon. As a result, we started to focus on growing at a faster rate, partially responsible for the mechanics burning out and leaving.

Partnering with a carpool startup also was a mistake because that it the workload tremendously.

In the end, I would focus on growing much slower and burning much less money by hyper-focusing in a very small community for an extended period of time.

What did you learn?

I learned a few things along this journey. Some of them are:

  • Never try to spend too much money on customer acquisition. Instead, look for organic and innovative methods to acquire clients.
  • Focus on retention and not on speed.
  • Customers were very happy with our service and I realized that the India customer experience needs to be improved tremendously, which also means a lot of opportunities to make a big difference from competitors.

Which are your favorite entrepreneurial resources?

Books:

Websites:

YouTube:

Tools:

  • Bubble: UI based tool to build responsive web apps
  • Canva: To design marketing materials and banners.
  • Fiverr: Hire a Logo designer
  • Tilda: Website builder
  • Mailjet: For marketing emails

 

Where can we go to learn more?

You can visit Autto.in website, which is still LIVE. Or you can also visit the Twitter account and Medium profile we had.

✉️ Subscribe to receive weekly startup related articles!

We’re always digging for more failure stories like Autto.In. Sign up for our newsletter to keep updated on the latest additions.

👇 Other Interviews

Emit: Raising $17,000 for a Productivity-Orientated Smartwatch
By 
Stephen Titus
  •  
April 9, 2019
United Kingdom
e-Commerce
Up to 50K
Lets Reach Success: How Lidiya Built a Personal Development Blog Earning $2,000/Month
By 
Lidiya K
  •  
February 21, 2019
Netherlands
Blog
Up to 50K
Rankd SEO: How to Build and Validate a Backlink Database in Less than a Month
By 
Martins Sulcs
  •  
May 1, 2019
Latvia
Analytics
Up to 50K
Joker Greeting: Making $30,000/Month Selling Prank Cards
By 
Travis Peterson
  •  
February 21, 2019
United States
e-Commerce
Up to 50K
Posture Keeper: Creating a Business to Solve My Back Pain
By 
Shirley Tan
  •  
February 21, 2019
United States
e-Commerce
No Data
Seomator: Growing a SaaS to $4k/month in a Highly Competitive Market
By 
Nick Sawinyh
  •  
February 21, 2019
United States
Web Application
Up to 50K
HitroNaSplet: Time Investment > Revenue = Wrong Direction
By 
Ales Krivec
  •  
March 17, 2018
Slovenia
Technology
Capital
Profitabilly: Shutting Down a Profitable Side-Project
By 
Natagon
  •  
May 9, 2019
Indonesia
SaaS
No Passion
ExploreVR: Losing $6,000 Building the TripAdvisor for VR
By 
Andrey Norin
  •  
April 26, 2018
United States
Web Application
Bad Marketing
The Punjab Kitchen: Failing to Overcome Competitors Prices
By 
Amit Gogia
  •  
August 30, 2018
India
Food
Big Competitors
Vivalatina: From Failure to Product-Market Fit Selling Online Jewelry
By 
Nicolas Tranchant
  •  
March 17, 2018
Mexico
e-Commerce
Bad Marketing
Bediwin Information Services: Shutting Down my IT Support Company
By 
James Cort
  •  
April 28, 2018
United Kingdom
Technology
Business Model